Tuesday, January 22, 2013

The Importance of Feedback

Something I have learned from my pretty much constant seven-month jump into the world of fanfic is that I cannot write in a vacuum. I'm my own worst critic, after all, and what I think is absolutely terrible may not be half bad, and what I think is nothing special may very well in fact be something special. (Seriously. "Can You Help Me" is at, of this writing, 86 favorites. I am completely confounded as to why.)

So I am once again offering something up for constructive criticism. Below is my rewritten prologue for The Witch of November. I wrote it in about forty-five minutes, so it's not polished and pretty but it's not worth taking the time to polish it up if it's not accomplishing what I need it to do. Does it grab you? Does the dialogue sound like you imagine two young women from the late 1870s would sound? Does it make you want to know what these two women have to do with the Witch in the title? Basically, does it do what a prologue should do?

Please help me out here. I want to get working on this sucker again, but it's so hard to do that when you think what you have is terrible and not working.


-----
 
August 24, 1877

Lillian Cobb had known the dangers inherent in accepting a fisherman's hand in marriage. She'd spent her entire twenty-two years in the fishing town of November, Maine, after all. She'd heard all the stories, watched with her own eyes as the cruel ocean took fathers from children and turned wives into widows. But try telling a blissfully happy twenty-two-year-old whose childhood sweetheart had just proposed marriage that maybe she should take a moment to think. She'd accepted Josiah Blackstone's proposal in a heartbeat, and the two had been married in a lovely church service on a snowy but oddly warm February day in 1876.

Lillian Cobb, on the day she'd become Lillian Blackstone, had taken the weather as a good omen. The snow was light and fluffy, falling from the sky in thick flakes but disappearing before it hit the ground. Eleven months later, she realized she should have seen it as a portent of things to come.

A sudden winter storm had claimed Josiah Blackstone's small but profitable vessel, along with every member of her four-man crew. Lillian was a left a twenty-four-year-old widow with an entire life ahead of her, a lifetime to spend without the only man she'd ever loved.

A knock on her front door startled Lillian from her morose reverie. When she peeked out the parlor curtain to check the identity of her visitor, she grinned. It was time.

She opened the door to an exuberant Mildred Albertson. “We couldn't have asked for better atmosphere,” Millie said as Lillian ushered her inside. “A storm's brewing, and if the thunder in the distance is any indication, it's going to be a whopper. Have you managed to obtain what I asked?”

“As much as I was able,” Lillian confirmed as she led Millie to her parlor. Earlier in the day, she'd pushed the armchairs and settee against the wall. The bench that usually took up residence underneath the keys of Lillian's mother's upright piano now sat in the hall. She'd set up an old card table of Josiah's in the middle of the room with a dining room chair on either side, facing each other. “I rescued that table from the attic this morning. It was the only thing I could think to use. Will it be all right?”

“It should do just fine, thank you,” Millie replied. She approached the table, set her satchel down at her feet, and began pulling item and item from it.

Lillian watched with both amazement and anticipation as Millie drew out a thick velvet cloth dyed such a deep purple it was almost black. She draped the cloth over the table, reverently ensuring the white circle printed on the velvet was centered. Five white candles followed, each set on the edge of the circle on the cloth, equidistant from each other. Jars of lavender and sage and other herbs that Lillian couldn't identify joined the candles on the table.

If Lillian remembered correctly, Millie had told her she would need the sage to perform a blessing to purify the space before beginning. It was purely a preparatory step, she'd said, but one that was necessary to ensure their safety.

It was only now that Millie's wording clicked with Lillian. Ensure their safety … but from what? She watched Millie pull the final item from her satchel, a small silver platter than reminded Lillian quite a bit of the offering plate at church.

How could Lillian ever show her face in church again after participating in something like this? Josiah wouldn't have wanted this for her. She knew that in her heart. Josiah wouldn't have wanted her to start listening to the town eccentric, wouldn't have wanted to invite this kind of thing into the sanctuary of their home.

But Josiah is no longer here, she told herself. In fact, Josiah not being there any longer was the whole point. How could she go through the rest of her life without him by her side?

She couldn't. It was that simple. She couldn't go through the rest of her life without him by her side, which was why she'd asked Millie to do what they were about to do.

That didn't mean she wasn't nervous, however. “Forgive me,” she spoke up as she watched Millie grind an unidentifiable sprig of … something with a mortar and pestle, “but aren't we in need of an expert for something like this?”

Millie looked up at her friend, amusement lighting her eyes. “I'm not an expert by now?”

“Of course you are,” Lillian sputtered. “I only meant that–”

“I'm aware of what you meant,” Millie assured the nervous widow. “You don't have to worry, Lillian. This ritual is perfectly safe. We'll be able to hear and understand–”

“'Hear and understand?' We won't be able to see them?”

Here, Millie hesitated. “Though I have seen my Caleb on occasion, I mostly only hear him.” Lillian's face fell, and Millie rushed to reassure her. “Oh, please don't get discouraged before we even begin, Lillian. I'm not telling you that you will never see Josiah. I'm only telling you that seeing a spirit is very rare.”

After a moment of deliberation, Lillian nodded. The misunderstand was, after all, her own fault. All Millie had offered her was a chance to speak with Josiah again. Lillian was the one who'd assumed they would be speaking face-to-face.

She watched as Millie performed the blessing, then lit the white candles on the table. At Millie's nod, Lillian sat down in the chair across from her friend. When Millie reached across the table, Lillian complied with the silent instruction, slipping her hands into her friend's grip. “Now what do we do?”

“We call to the spirits,” Millie said, squeezing Lillian's hands for reassurance, “and we wait for an answer.”

0 comments:

Post a Comment